blogger profileblogger profile
Alison Skirtboston
Skirt! Boston editor
Skirt! is evidence that the universe is paying attention: I spent the last six years at mach speed, whether finishing college (Emerson) while writing full time for Boston Globe West (2001-2004) or editing the Boston Parents’ Paper during the day while holding down the steady gig writing for Globe ...
blog entryblog entry

I Like Sarah Palin

Thursday, September, 4, 2008

Does that shock you? Were you expecting another tirade about her tokenism and lack of feminine values (hey, did I coin a new phrase?)?

Sure, she somehow believes that abstinence is appropriate birth control for hormone-crazed teenagers, she doesn’t support a woman’s right to choose, and she’s playing second fiddle to a guy (John McCain) who chose her for her body parts other than her brain, but I think she’s kind of cool.

She fishes, she’s got an interesting past (beauty queen?? I’d like to hear the behind-the-scenes stories from the Miss Wasila pageant!), she’s got a temper (trying to get her State Trooper brother-in-law fired) and she rose to become first female governor of a decidedly testosterone-fueled state, Alaska. Face it, she rocks.

And exaggerating her experience while downplaying the truth of some of her political decisions? That’s just part of playing in the same arena as the boys. Why should a woman be held to a higher standard than her opponents just because they are anatomically different?

palin.jpghillary.jpg
 Both are working women, so let’s put that set of criticisms aside.

As women, we have to separate our knee-jerk reactions from the facts. The facts are that life is complicated, that teenaged daughters get pregnant sometimes even in the nicest families (no fewer than 5 of my friends from high school got pregnant and kept their babies; I don’t know how many opted out of their pregnancies). But above all – hope this doesn’t shock you – mothers work.

Why are so many women reduced to shrill old biddies when it comes to Sarah Palin? How do you think Hillary Rodham Clinton gained the experience she claimed in her presidential bid, by staying home and knitting mittens for Chelsea? No, in fact, Hillary was a pretty high-powered attorney, a career that’s among the most difficult for mothers to juggle.

I haven’t heard much about Sarah Palin’s husband, or others in her support system, but I’d like to. I think it would be instructive for the rest of us to understand how she rose to her position. The most successful working women I’ve met – including the CEO of Emerson Hospital – are honest about their dependence on others when it comes to the compromises they make to have both a career and a family. And that in itself shouldn’t be a reason to criticize her.

We like to complain that there are few women in politics, but we don’t like the reality of the sacrifices that are required to be a successful female politician. We like to call certain women role models, but we want to pick apart their successes and drain their true value at the same time.

So, dislike her politics, but don’t diss the woman. Come November, this hockey mom may create the deepest fracture yet in the almighty glass ceiling of Washington DC.


krrobi
krrobi
Posted Thu, 09/04/2008 - 10:22
You have guts to write this! I feel the same way... listening to women at work dis this woman about her hair, pregnant daughter, lack of experience. I say, throw the first stone, honey. I think Palin is real, somebody we can identify with, somebody with real problems, like us. And although, I'm voting for Obama, I still respect a woman who stands up with elequence and speaks her truth. I am actually surprised at how people are responding to Palin...they are darn right nasty, and damn it, she's a hockey mom!
getaclewis
getaclewis
Posted Thu, 09/04/2008 - 10:54
Alison, this is one of those "Wish I could've said it as eloquently as that" columns for me. Attaboy (no wait... attagirl!) to Sarah for what she has achieved (and what, so far as we can yet see, appears to be a rather happy family behind her) and attagirl to you for saying so (& saying it so well). "Trust Life's unfolding..."
Sara Conrad
Sara Conrad
Posted Thu, 09/04/2008 - 13:47
I wouldn't go as far as to say I like Sarah Palin, because although I can get along with people who don't support women's rights (they're everywhere--life would be impossible without having to get along with them)I don't want them making decisions for me. I think you're right; she should be respected and more importantly, not disrespected in any way because of her gender, her family, or her life experiences. I respect her, but I sure as heck won't vote for her. If she's not for women's rights, I don't want her choosing for me. I think it's awesome that you're sticking up for her, though. I truly believe all women need to support eachother in making their own decisions...even for women that, well, don't support each other. But I'm not supporting her on the ballot. ~Sara
alison skirtboston
alison skirtboston
Posted Thu, 09/04/2008 - 14:39
all of the catfighting about her ability to mother and hold down a job is distracting us from having real conversations about her qualifications (comparisons to the Democratic ticket) and her political stance (doubting global warming, etc). I hope it dies down soon and allows us to focus on what's important for our country (and our gender) in the future.
Sara Conrad
Sara Conrad
Posted Thu, 09/04/2008 - 17:44
I totally agree! Comparing women's mothering ability totally fires me up, too. We're not electing our parents, we're electing the president. Unfortunately, I think people are still judging women based on their mothering choices. I feel like mothering is such an important, personal part of life. To each her own.~Sara
ReneeCK
ReneeCK
Posted Thu, 09/04/2008 - 20:32
What struck me when I heard Sarah speak for the first time is that she belongs here- and by here I mean in my kitchen at the table drinking a glass of wine simply because we made it through Tuesday.

I can see Sarah Palin being in my circle of girls. Someone I could agree to disagree with, admire the way she continues to plug her "Maverick", and all the while shake my head and say "damn girl, this is a fine mess you've gotten yourself into".
alison skirtboston
alison skirtboston
Posted Thu, 09/04/2008 - 22:22
Like the people who voted for George W., I think she'd be fun to have a beer with..then maybe go shoot holes in some street signs out the window of her truck.... but seriously, I wrote what I did because I know so many people whose lives have diverged from mine, whose values I shared in the past but who sound so much like Sarah Palin now. I don't disrespect them, or pick on their small faults because we disagree on some philosophical things. We're all struggling with the choices in front of us, and hold tight to the belief that our principles will see us through. We may not share the same path but she deserves credit for her successes and for sticking to her guns. (heh heh)
gojigrl
gojigrl
Posted Thu, 09/04/2008 - 22:26
I totally agree. Life happens but look beyond that and look at the facts. This is about who we want with the right qualities to run this country. Like Leadership, Integrity, Trust, and Honesty to name a few. Need to accentuate the positive and get away from the knit picking. The media and newspapers are good at that. Make your own decision and go on the merit of the individual. Not on the negative news in the paper and TV. WE all have choices and let it be on the facts not superficial attacks. Anella www.DrinkYourselfRich.com
nikki
nikki
Posted Fri, 09/05/2008 - 06:26
The facts are that she doesn't believe women should have control over their own bodies, that humans don't cause global warming, that creationism is the science our kids need to learn while kids in China and Russia study physics. I don't care about her family problems or her hairdo or her ability to shoot a moose--I care about what her election means for feminism and women's rights. What the hell have we been fighting for all these years? But maybe I'm just one of those shrill voices who should shut up, lighten up and have a beer with Sarah and George. ~nikki
faun
faun
Posted Fri, 09/05/2008 - 09:21
I like a lot of people I would never vote into office. I'm not ready to put aside my core values to elect Palin. Woman or not. What's happening here? Are we really so drunk on the idea of a woman being in such a high-ranking office that we subjugate our intellect? Our common sense? Our convictions? This equates to gender at any cost. C'mon, this is beneath most women and what we - and our blessed ancestors who fought for our right to vote - have striven for all these years. Consider this: Would her platform, her background, her record entice you to vote for her if she were a man?
Sara Conrad
Sara Conrad
Posted Mon, 09/08/2008 - 12:00
Well said!! It's kind of sexism, too, if some people are favoring her because she's a woman...and really counterproductive since she doesn't stand for women. I think it's insulting to women that McCain thinks by choosing a woman for VP on his ticket that women will automaticall vote for him. Like I said, we're not monkeys. He's not giving us any credit at all as women...it's kind of sexist,actually. http://jacksonville.skirt.com/node/10163 (my title is sarcastic...I think we need an emoiticon for sarcasm). ~Sara
becks
becks
Posted Fri, 09/05/2008 - 12:57
The thing that bothers me is not the fact that she's a working mother but the fact that Republicans are supposed to be the party of 'the family' and would in normal circumstances express outrage at her perceived abandonment of her young child. However, because it suits them politically to support her, they forget all their previous opposition to working mothers. It is the hypocrisy of the Republicans that drives the criticism at the moment - All this talk about running against the Washington elite just highlights how much a part of the Washington elite they have been for the past 30 years. Nothing will change in Washington just because one Republican Vice-Presidential candidate says it will.
alison skirtboston
alison skirtboston
Posted Fri, 09/05/2008 - 15:32
This virtual conversation has been soul food for me. We're on deadline this week and don't have much time to hash over Palin's strengths and weaknesses, or the FABULOUS points made by previous posters on this topic (I know, I never imagined the Republicans co-opting the Democrats by nominating a woman! wow!). The question is, are women having this deep conversation on a national level, or are we just skimming the surface of the important issues? I'm so glad skirt can play a role in raising the conversation to a higher level.
Aleigh
Aleigh
Posted Tue, 09/09/2008 - 15:46
I really don't think a woman politician "rocks" because she can shoot a gun or would be fun to have a beer with. The mainstream media may be distracting some people from her politics, but her stances on all of the things you mentioned -- abortion rights, gun control, ethics, etc. -- are all reasons why I DON'T like Sarah Palin. I don't see how it's a good thing that she tried to use her role as governor of Alaska to get her ex-brother-in-law fired. That's the same kind of "you're either with us or against us" mindset that has gotten us into so much trouble with George W Bush when it comes to foreign policy. Call me a shrill old biddie if you will, but I refuse to support a politician with my vote--man OR woman--just because they might be fun at a party. And I wouldn't call Sarah Palin a role model, either.
Charlene Ross
Charlene Ross
Posted Thu, 09/11/2008 - 08:09
My biggest problem with Palin is her extreme anti-choice stance. Joe Biden is a strict Catholic who does not believe in abortion, yet votes for women's rights to chose because he is fairminded enough to realize that HIS relious beliefs are just that - HIS beliefs and he has no business imposing that on the women of our country. Beyond that, what I'd really like is to see Sarah Palin ANSWER some questions, not just read from a very well crafted script that she rehearsed in a closed room for 5 days. I don't dislike Sarah Palin as a person (how could I, I don't even know her) even though I disagree with everything she stands for - but I do find it insulting that the Republican party thinks any smart woman will do as a Hillary replacement. This woman is no Hillary. Her forgeign policy experience has been described (by Cindy McCain) as strong because Alaska is the closest state to Russia! WTF? Yes, truly if she were a man she never would have been chosen. Like her if you want, but please don't vote for her! (Unless of course you want women's rights taken away, global warming to increase, and a stupid senseless war that has killed over 1million people - that number is correct it's not only American's dying over there - to go on forever.)